13 Of The Best Tubing Mascaras For Bolder, Smudge-Proof Lashes

We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article.

Panda eyes? Never heard of them.

As a beauty writer, new mascaras can be a point of great contention in my beauty routine. There's nothing quite as humbling as walking into the office bathroom only to be confronted with the panda eyes worthy of London Zoo. Luckily, the beauty industry is boasting a new generation of tubing mascaras, the saviour for those who can't bear the flaking, smudging or almost-impossible removal of traditional formulas (never mind a stay-all-day waterproof mascara).

In turn, the ELLE UK beauty team and I have been on a venture to find very best tubing mascaras, trialling and testing for our different eye shapes and lash needs, as well as trying them out against our end-of-day cleanses. These are the ones we truly rate.

Tubing' refers to a unique mascara technology that, instead of washing the lashes in a layer of pigment, actually wraps micro-fibres around them, which then dry to form a flexible 'tube' that grips on. Traditionally they don't give a lightweight fluffy look (if that's what you're after), but can be built up to give impressive length, definition and drama. They're truly smudge free, meaning you won't end up with pigment all over your brow bone or shadows of soot under the eyes.

The best thing about a tubing mascara, for most fans, is how easily it is removed. It's probably the reason you'll be familiar with them, if TikTok is how you were introduced. When they come into contact with warm water, the formula 'relaxes', and (should, if it's a true tubing formula) slide or be easily plucked from the lashes in soft clumps. No panda eyes, and no scrubbing at the sensitive eye area.

There are two reasons that one might switch to a tubing mascara formula; the first is that you're just a little lazy when it comes to washing away your make-up. No judgement here. If you find that breaking down your lash formula with a cleansing balm or oil is too much faff, or too much for more sensitive skin types, a tubing mascara offers a more gentle alternative to the traditional take-off process.

The other reason is that your watery eyes interfere with your mascara throughout the day. Whether you're a frequent crier, having naturally leaky eyes or you're prone to hay fever and other tearful conditions, a tubing mascara will dramatically reduce the risk of smudging and streaking.

For many, once you turn to tubing, you never look back. From Hourglass to Clinique, meet the innovative tubing technologies we're switching to in 2024.

This bold mascara is the ultimate party season companion. Offering thick, inky lashes without any of that dreadful clumping, this new Charlotte Tilbury launch has become a favourite of the beauty team. The best part? It won't move an inch, whether you're sporting a smoky eye or a graphic eyeliner.

A true tubing mascara (in the way it applies and the way it removes - in satisfying squishy clumps when immersed in warm water) this one ticks all the boxes for tubing superfans. As a bonus, it also gives incredible length and drama.

Beauty Pie's USP has always been about bringing the most advanced technology and luxury products at more affordable price points to all us beauty obsessives. This innovative tubing mascara is no exception, offering a high-tech formula that surrounds every single one of your lashes. The result: no dreaded smudges or creasing, and an extra-glossy finish.

Merit Beauty is all about a natural, 'clean girl' aesthetic, but even clean girls want show-stopping lashes. Despite the tubing formula, this finish is nice and fluffy.

They promised 'long and defined' and they meant it: the length this formula gives is seriously impressive. Lashes will be separated but not spidery (just take your time when layering up to avoid clumping).

Fans of a believably lengthened lash will adore this separating mascara. Complete with a fine plastic comb, this beloved formula provides subtle definition and an inky black tint without ever looking clumpy or thick.

Blink Brow Bar has transcended the world of sleek brow perfecting and is now refining, lengthening and nourishing lacklustre eye looks. This tubing formula not only enhances your natural flutter with generous pigment, it also harnesses the power of vitamins E and B and a jojoba wax for truly stronger lash over time.

Created by Euphoria make-up artist Donni Davy, we trust Half Magic Beauty to deliver when it comes to ethereal glitters and structured eyeliners. But did you know their tubing mascara is also in our top tier? In three playful shades (black, blue and pink) this is designed to volumise and lengthen without a flake in sight.

Waterproof mascaras are notoriously difficult to remove, but this nifty tubing formula makes it ever-so-easy. Despite sliding away seamlessly with just a splash of water, this fluffy texture boasts a whopping 48 hours of wear time.

This Zero Gravity iteration of Clinique's classic High Impact mascara is all about that lift. With a tubing formula, it curls and lifts lashes to new heights – but without a smudge in sight.

Often seen as the OG of tubing mascaras, this one has stood the test of time and is still a favourite today. The finish is strikingly glossy and dramatically volumising: honestly, if you're new to tubing formulas, start here.

If you want the effortless removal but prefer a hyper-natural look, this is the pick for you. It does build to add length, but not full-on drama. A great option for day-to-day use.

This affordable formula layers lashes with buildable tubing technology, adding length and volume to any lacklustre eye look. Perfect for anyone seeking a new favourite high-street mascara. Did we mention it also comes in three shades? Pitch black, soft black and brown.

Mejuri's Black Friday Sale Is Approaching

The Spot Treatments Dermatologists Recommend

The Best Jeans For Women – Ever

The Best DD+ Swimwear To Buy For Big Boobs

ELLE Edit: The 17 Best Bronzers

A Dupe For Becca's Legendary Under-Eye Corrector

ELLE Edit: The Best BB Creams Of All Time

The Best SPF Moisturisers For All Year Round

Can A Hard Water Shower Filter Change Your Hair?

ELLE Edit: The Best SPFs For Acne-Prone Skin

The Black Friday Fashion Deals Directory

The Best Lingerie Brands To Have On Your Radar